Official media partner of business and marketing eventsEvents calendar
VANTAGE52

Loading market data

Strategy

EU Court Adviser Kokott Backs Reopening Google’s €1.5 Billion AdSense Fine

Advocate General Juliane Kokott’s opinion of 12 November is advice the judges may reject. If they follow it, the 2024 annulment falls, the General Court must rule again, and any restored fine would be smaller than the original.

Night collage of the gold towers of the EU Court of Justice in Luxembourg with a laptop on a courtroom bench showing Google search results with ads, a bound contract and judges’ robes behind a lit window
Illustration by VANTAGE52
VANTAGE52 Editorial · Edited by VANTAGE52 Editorial

An adviser to the European Union’s highest court has told its judges that Google should not have escaped its almost €1.5 billion AdSense fine. In an opinion delivered on 12 November in Case C-826/24 P, Advocate General Juliane Kokott proposed that the Court of Justice set aside the 2024 judgment that annulled the fine and send the case back to the General Court for a fresh ruling.

Her opinion decides nothing on its own. The court’s press release states that it “is not binding on the Court of Justice” and that the judges “are now beginning their deliberations in this case”, with judgment to be given at a later date. No date has been set, and until the judges rule, the 2024 judgment that cancelled the Commission’s decision remains in force.

The stakes run beyond one fine. The appeal asks how much work the European Commission must do to prove that a dominant company’s exclusive contracts shut out rivals. The General Court demanded a detailed, contract-by-contract look at how long customers were bound. Kokott’s answer is that the law asks for less.

Three Clauses in a Publisher Contract

The case concerns AdSense for Search, the Google service that let websites with their own search boxes show Google search ads and take a share of the revenue. Larger publishers negotiated a Google Services Agreement, and the model contracts Google used from March 2009 carried three clauses the Commission objected to.

An exclusivity clause barred publishers from using competing search ad services on the sites concerned. A placement clause required a minimum number of Google ads and kept rival ads away from the top position and from directly beside Google’s. A prior authorisation clause obliged publishers to get Google’s approval before changing how ads were displayed.

Complaints began with a German company in 2010 and later came from Microsoft, Expedia and Deutsche Telekom, according to the General Court. In March 2019 the Commission found a single and continuous infringement running from January 2006 to September 2016 and fined Google €1.49 billion, of which about €130 million jointly with its parent, Alphabet. Google had already removed or amended the clauses in September 2016.

Where Kokott Says the General Court Went Wrong

On 18 September 2024 the General Court upheld most of the Commission’s findings but annulled the whole decision. Many of the agreements individually ran for only a few years, the judges noted, and the Commission had looked at their cumulative duration without checking whether publishers could switch to a rival when contracts were renewed or by using a right to terminate.

Kokott takes issue with the method rather than the facts. Duration is one of the criteria the Court of Justice set out in its 2017 Intel judgment for deciding whether a dominant firm’s exclusive commitments foreclose competitors. In her view the General Court treated that one criterion as a hurdle in its own right and “imposed excessive requirements as to the scope of the examination of the criterion of duration”.

The Commission does not have to dissect each contract, she argues. It is enough, in principle, to consider together all the contracts that matter for competition in the market, with their durations, and to show that collectively they were capable of excluding rivals. In her reading the Commission did that, partly by relying on averages. Because the exclusionary effects were established, she adds, the General Court was also wrong to reject the finding of a single and continuous infringement.

A Smaller Bill Even if the Commission Wins

Even on Kokott’s reading, the full €1.49 billion would not simply return. The Commission did not appeal the General Court’s finding that exclusionary effects were not shown for 2016, so that part of the annulment is final. Its appeal asks the court to restore the infringement only for the period from 31 March 2009 to 31 December 2015.

Kokott says the fine should be reduced in any event, and that the General Court must still hear Google’s objections to the amount, which it never reached in 2024. That is why she proposes a referral rather than a final ruling. As the court’s own notes on appeals explain, the Court of Justice may give final judgment itself where the state of the proceedings permits. Otherwise it sends the case back to the General Court, which is then bound by the appeal ruling.

The parties set out their positions at a hearing in July. Josh Holmes, for Google, told a five-judge panel that “the Commission’s new arguments are flawed”, Reuters reported, while Anthony Dawes, for the Commission, said the lower court’s finding “turns case law on its head”.

What Dominant Firms’ Distribution Deals Stand to Lose

For any company with a dominant position, the practical issue is the burden of proof. Under the General Court’s approach, the Commission had to show in detail, criterion by criterion, that contracts locked customers in for long enough to matter, including at each renewal. Under Kokott’s approach it can assess a network of contracts together. If the judges agree, exclusivity and placement terms in a dominant firm’s distribution contracts become easier for Brussels to attack, whatever the industry.

The opinion lands in a wider argument about how hard Europe should press large companies. VANTAGE52 has examined whether Europe needs bigger companies to compete, and how Brussels chose conditions over a prohibition in the terms attached to JD.com’s takeover of Ceconomy that open its logistics to rivals. AdSense tests the older tool, an abuse case built on contracts that were rewritten a decade ago.

For Google, the case sits in a crowded docket. The Android fine of about €4.1 billion became final on 2 July, and The Next Web noted that Google is contesting a separate EU fine of almost €3 billion over its advertising technology business. The same publication counted AdSense as the only one of Google’s six EU antitrust fines that a court had overturned. The opinion puts that one win in doubt.

Eight to Twelve Months, if Precedent Holds

The court has given no date for judgment, but its own record in Kokott’s two earlier Google appeals offers a guide. In Google Shopping she delivered her opinion on 11 January 2024, and the court upheld the €2.4 billion fine on 10 September 2024, eight months later. In Google Android her opinion came on 19 June 2025, and the court confirmed the fine on 2 July 2026, just over a year later. Both times the judges followed her advice.

On that pattern, a judgment in the AdSense appeal would arrive between the summer and the end of 2027, and The Next Web reported that a ruling is expected next year. A referral would then add another round. The General Court would have to decide Google’s remaining arguments and the amount, and its new judgment could itself be appealed on points of law.

The next dated step is the court listing C-826/24 P for judgment. Until then, the 2024 annulment stands, and the €1.49 billion figure is a ceiling rather than a bill.

Tags

Share this story

Sources

Where the reporting above comes from. Follow these to check the figures and statements for yourself.

More From Ideas

Choose which cookies we may use. You can change this at any time from “Manage cookies” at the foot of every page.