Official media partner of business and marketing eventsEvents calendar
VANTAGE52

Loading market data

Leadership

ISS and Glass Lewis Oppose Tesla Chair Robyn Denholm, and Tesla Calls Them Myopic

Both proxy advisers say the board ignored a 2025 vote for annual director elections, and Glass Lewis adds board diversity. Tesla’s 18 November filing answers them point by point before the 3 December meeting.

Night collage of an empty factory hall set for a Tesla shareholder meeting, rows of chairs facing a screen with the Tesla logo, scattered voting cards and a boardroom table with one chair pulled out
Illustration by VANTAGE52
VANTAGE52 Editorial · Edited by VANTAGE52 Editorial

Tesla’s board has told shareholders that the two biggest proxy advisers are wrong about its chair. In a letter filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission on 18 November, the company called the recommendations by Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) and Glass Lewis to vote against re-electing Robyn Denholm “myopic, misguided and based on misconceptions.”

Denholm, chair since November 2018, is one of three directors standing for three-year terms at the annual meeting on 3 December, with Elon Musk and JB Straubel. Bloomberg News reported on 19 November that ISS supported the rest of Tesla’s ballot, including Musk and Straubel. Each nominee needs a majority of the shares present or represented at the meeting.

The advisers’ reports go to their paying clients and are not public. Their reasoning below is as Tesla quotes it in its filing and as Bloomberg reported it.

The 2025 Vote at the Centre of the Dispute

The shared objection goes back to Tesla’s annual meeting on 6 November 2025. A shareholder proposal asking for every director to be elected each year passed, with about 1.33 billion shares for and 1.12 billion against, according to Tesla’s filing of the results. That is roughly 54% of the shares voted for or against.

Tesla’s letter summarises the advisers’ view that the board has been “insufficiently responsive” to that proposal and should have put a binding declassification proposal to shareholders this year. The 2026 ballot has three items instead, the director election, an advisory vote on 2025 pay and the reappointment of PricewaterhouseCoopers as auditor.

Glass Lewis adds a second reason. Tesla quotes it as saying that “no sufficient rationale has been provided for the low level of Board gender diversity, nor has a timetable been provided,” and as holding Denholm responsible as the longest-serving member of the nominating and corporate governance committee who is up for election. Two of Tesla’s nine directors, Denholm and Kathleen Wilson-Thompson, are women.

Tesla’s Step-by-Step Defence

Tesla argues that a binding proposal would simply have failed. Its staggered board is written into its Texas certificate of formation, and changing that article takes the votes of two-thirds of all outstanding shares. In 2025 the board’s own proposal to remove supermajority requirements won the support of about 39.4% of outstanding shares, the October proxy says, and the letter lists failed binding attempts to remove those requirements in 2019, 2021, 2022 and 2025.

The board calls its approach “deliberative, step-wise”, clearing the supermajority hurdle first so that declassification could later pass on a lower threshold. It notes that an advisory shareholder proposal on supermajority voting drew only 32% of votes present in 2025. “Clearly, any claims that Tesla has been ‘insufficiently responsive’ to shareholder feedback on the matter are simply untrue,” the letter says.

On diversity, the letter calls it “the utmost irony” that Glass Lewis would oppose a woman on the grounds that the board needs more women. It notes that Glass Lewis also opposed Wilson-Thompson last year, when she was re-elected with more than 78% of votes cast.

The Record Tesla Puts Forward

Most of the five-page letter argues from Denholm’s tenure. Tesla says its market value rose from about $60 billion on 7 November 2018, when her appointment was announced, to more than $1.5 trillion on 13 November 2026, and puts total shareholder return over the period at about 1,581%, citing FactSet. It credits her with proxy access in 2022, three independent directors added since 2022 and the new retail voting programme, and notes that she also chairs the audit committee.

The letter also attacks the advisers’ model. It says ISS and Glass Lewis “own no Tesla shares”, apply “one-size-fits-all” frameworks and have disclosed in recent litigation that they lack the infrastructure to integrate company-specific financial analysis, without naming the cases. It recalls that both opposed Musk’s 2025 performance award, which Tesla says was approved by 75% of votes cast, and the 2024 ratification of his 2018 award, which Tesla says drew about 77%.

Why Protests Rarely Unseat Tesla Directors

Adviser opposition has dented votes at Tesla without changing outcomes. In 2020 ISS opposed Denholm, and Glass Lewis did too until September of that year, when it reversed after Tesla replaced a directors’ insurance arrangement Musk had personally provided, Reuters reported at the time. She was re-elected with about 81% of the shares voted on her seat.

At the 2025 meeting the largest protest was against Ira Ehrenpreis, re-elected with about 1.59 billion shares for, 859 million against and 16 million abstaining, or roughly 65% support.

The arithmetic leans toward the board. Musk directs the vote of about 699.6 million shares, 19.8% by the proxy’s count, and is on the same ballot. The 423.7 million shares of his unearned 2025 award are voted in the same proportions as all other shares present, which leaves the percentages unchanged. Under the majority-of-shares-present standard, abstentions count against a nominee.

Tesla is also building a retail counterweight to the advisers. Its Voluntary Retail Voting Program, promoted in a filing on 17 November, lets individual holders give a standing instruction to vote with the board at future meetings, with an option to carve out contested director elections and deals that need a shareholder vote. Enrolment does not affect this year’s ballot.

Tesla is not alone in resetting the balance between a founder, the board and outside investors. Anthropic’s planned listing fixes a 50.1% founder vote from the start, and Nvidia turned to a first-ever chair after Jensen Huang’s resignation, a separation of roles Tesla has had since Denholm became its independent chair in 2018.

What the Count on 3 December Will Show

Voting closes at 11.59pm Eastern Time on 2 December for most holders, and the meeting opens at 3pm Central Time, online and at Gigafactory Texas. Tesla filed last year’s tallies the day after the meeting.

The figure to watch is the share of votes against Denholm or abstaining. A result close to the 35% recorded against or abstaining on Ehrenpreis last year would show that a large bloc of institutions shares the advisers’ view on declassification, even if she is comfortably re-elected. It would also land as a Tesla special committee weighs a possible combination with SpaceX, which Bloomberg has reported could be announced as soon as December. A much smaller protest would suggest that Tesla’s step-wise argument, and its appeal to retail holders, is winning.

Tags

Key Concepts

Share this story

Sources

Where the reporting above comes from. Follow these to check the figures and statements for yourself.

More From Ideas

Choose which cookies we may use. You can change this at any time from “Manage cookies” at the foot of every page.