Official media partner of business and marketing eventsEvents calendar
VANTAGE52

Loading market data

Markets

Musk Says a SpaceX Merger Should Not Earn Him Tesla Pay as Talks Progress

Bloomberg reports a deal could be announced as soon as December. Tesla’s filings show its 2025 award already raises Musk’s targets after a large acquisition, but a change in control would test market value alone.

Night collage of a Tesla Cybertruck with two stacks of share certificates on its bonnet, parked at a fence in front of a floodlit rocket on its launch tower
Illustration by VANTAGE52
VANTAGE52 Editorial · Edited by VANTAGE52 Editorial

Elon Musk said on 18 November that any combination of SpaceX and Tesla would need shareholder approval that “may or may not succeed”, and that he should not be rewarded “just for doing a merger”. He was speaking to Andrew Ross Sorkin at The New York Times DealBook Summit, CNBC reported.

They came six days after Bloomberg News reported, citing people familiar with the matter, that merger talks between the two companies Musk runs were progressing and that an announcement could come as soon as December, with a slip into early 2027 also discussed. Nothing has been signed and no terms are public. Neither company commented on the report.

Reuters, summarising the Bloomberg story, put the market values at the last close at about $1.90 trillion for SpaceX and $1.55 trillion for Tesla. Bloomberg called it what would be the largest deal on record.

For Tesla shareholders the pay question is concrete. Musk’s 2025 award of about 423.7 million restricted shares, approved on 6 November 2025, has separate clauses for acquisitions and for a change in control of Tesla, and they would treat a SpaceX deal very differently depending on how it is built.

What Is Reported and What Tesla Has Filed

Reuters added that the deal faces regulatory hurdles over SpaceX’s US defence contracts and Tesla’s reliance on China. On SpaceX’s third-quarter earnings call in October, Musk called a merger “a good idea” and said each company had formed a special committee of independent directors, Reuters reported.

Tesla’s side of that is in writing. Its quarterly report, filed on 22 October, says the board formed a special committee of disinterested directors to explore deepening Tesla’s relationship with SpaceX, possibly through a business combination, and that any transaction would need the committee’s recommendation and “any necessary shareholder approval.”

Tesla already owns a small piece of SpaceX. It invested $2.00 billion in March, in a stake that began as preferred shares in xAI Holdings and became SpaceX common stock after SpaceX acquired xAI Holdings on 2 February. The filing puts the interest at less than 1%, worth $2.865 billion on 30 September after an $863 million gain this year. Sale restrictions tied to SpaceX’s initial public offering expire in December.

The companies also trade with each other. SpaceX bought $626 million of Megapack batteries from Tesla in the first nine months of 2026 and owed it $729 million at the end of September. Tesla’s 3 December annual meeting carries no merger proposal.

Musk’s Case at DealBook

Musk argued that overlaps between the companies now exist that “didn’t exist before”, pointing to artificial intelligence, robotics and the AI software and chip-design teams at both. It is the same AI and robotics agenda behind his September forecast that AI could surpass humanity’s combined intelligence within five years.

He also said he could not force through a deal that was bad for shareholders because he would “obviously get sued”. In the same interview he called Jensen Huang irreplaceable, following Huang’s resignation as Nvidia’s chief executive.

Asked whether he should receive his Tesla award if a merger closed, Musk said he should be paid only if Tesla meets its performance targets. That is his stated view, not a term of any agreement, and Tesla has filed nothing on how a deal would treat the award.

How the 2025 Award Treats an Acquisition

The award is split into 12 tranches of 35,311,992 shares. Each is earned only when Tesla reaches a market value milestone, from $2.0 trillion to $8.5 trillion on six-month and 30-day trailing averages, and also meets one of 12 operational goals, such as 20 million vehicles delivered or Adjusted EBITDA of up to $400 billion. Tesla’s October proxy says no tranche has been earned.

The 2025 proxy sets out what happens if Tesla buys a company for more than $20 billion. Every unearned market value milestone rises by the purchase price. If the target earned more than $2 billion of Adjusted EBITDA over the previous four quarters, the profit milestones rise by that amount, and the disinterested directors can adjust the product goals. Tesla says the clause is meant to stop milestones being met through acquisitions.

In a deal in which Tesla absorbs SpaceX, the first milestone would therefore move up by whatever Tesla paid. At a price equal to the $1.90 trillion Reuters cited, it would sit near $3.9 trillion, above the two companies’ combined value of about $3.45 trillion at the same close. On that route the merger by itself would earn Musk nothing, which is consistent with what he said.

The Change in Control Clause

A second clause works differently. If a deal counts as a change in control of Tesla, tranches are tested on market value alone, with no operational goal. Market value is Tesla’s shares outstanding multiplied by the higher of the last closing price and the price per share paid in the deal. Earned shares vest at once and every tranche not earned is forfeited.

Among its triggers, the award agreement counts as a change in control a transaction in which another company’s owners, treated as a group, end up with more than half of Tesla’s voting power, unless Tesla’s existing holders keep at least half of the voting power of Tesla or its ultimate parent. At the values Reuters cited, SpaceX is the larger of the two. Which clause would apply depends on a structure nobody has published.

At about $1.55 trillion, Tesla is below the $2.0 trillion first milestone, so a change in control at a price near that value would earn no tranche and would forfeit the rest. A price valuing Tesla at $2.0 trillion or more would earn at least one.

The older award matters too. After the Delaware Supreme Court reinstated Musk’s 2018 options on 19 December 2025, he exercised all 303,960,630 of them on 16 June and received 286,428,773 restricted shares that vest on 19 January 2028. Under the agreement Tesla’s board approved in April, they vest early on a change in control if he is still serving as chief executive or in a product or operations role.

Who Would Have the Final Say

Tesla’s Texas certificate of formation lets a majority of the shares outstanding and entitled to vote approve a merger. Carliss Chatman of Southern Methodist University’s law school noted in a Bloomberg Law column on 9 November that Texas otherwise requires two-thirds. With 3,952,730,153 shares outstanding on the 13 October record date, a majority means roughly 1.98 billion votes in favour, and shares that do not vote count against.

Musk directs the vote of 699,580,882 shares, 19.8% by the proxy’s count, which leaves out his 423.7 million unearned award shares. Those are voted in the same proportions as all other shares present. Chatman wrote that nothing in Texas law bars Musk from voting his shares and that a majority-of-disinterested-holders condition would have to be negotiated.

Retail investors who join Tesla’s new standing voting programme can choose to exclude mergers that need a shareholder vote from their instruction to follow the board. Texas’s attorney general-elect, Nathan Johnson, who takes office in January, told Bloomberg on 13 November that he would look closely. “Any merger of companies of that consequence warrants tremendous scrutiny,” he said.

Three Markers in December

Tesla’s shareholders meet on 3 December, when board chair Robyn Denholm faces opposition from the proxy advisers ISS and Glass Lewis, a separate test of the board that would oversee any deal. The restrictions on Tesla’s SpaceX stake lapse the same month.

If Bloomberg’s sources are right, an announcement could follow in December. The exchange ratio, the structure and the treatment of Musk’s award would then sit in a filing rather than an interview, and shareholders could see which of the two clauses applies.

Tags

Key Concepts

Share this story

Sources

Where the reporting above comes from. Follow these to check the figures and statements for yourself.

More From Markets

Choose which cookies we may use. You can change this at any time from “Manage cookies” at the foot of every page.